Orchestrata Ultimate › Sessions › Session 250

Session 250

‹ previous · next › · timeline

Prose pending.

Record 1 — 2026-07-21 08:59 · Claude Opus 4.6 · archive (context.history.md)

Purpose

Build Phase 1 of the Prolog governance wiring plan: check_prolog_boundary.py gate + tests + wiring into health_check/code-review/run_tests

Objectives

• AST-discover Prolog query sites
• Consult shipped .pl into real janus and check existence
• Wire into 3 gates
• Real-infra tests, no mocks

Work log

• Built the Prolog boundary gate and wired it into health_check.py, code-review.py (BOUNDARY), run_tests.py gates at 2026-07-21 08:59 Details:
  • Discovery handles direct seam calls, executor indirection, and multi-hop passthrough helpers (F2 shape)
  • Full-corpus existence check via current_predicate(_:F/A) against load_governance_rules() + every other shipped .pl
  • 38-entry WHITELIST for genuinely-dynamic sites with justifications
  • Live gate found 5 real defects beyond the original 8 (which the concurrent P2 builder fixed during this session)
• W3 L-D2+L-D4 landed: generated intent lexicon + canonical re-exports (commit c980f8af, pushed) at 2026-07-21 09:00 Details:
  • intent_lexicon.gen.pl (58+26 facts) generated from IntentVocabulary.default() by scripts/gen_intent_lexicon.py; intent_grammar.pl includes it (16+13 silently-missing keywords now live — 'cleanup the parser module' classifies REFACTOR/CODE via DCG tier). schema.py/types_enums.py constants re-export canonical_schema (21+12 labels/rels + 12 enum members; Method/UnresolvedCall/UnresolvedClass/Document stay hand-authored per canon deferral). CI: wired gen_level0.py --check AND gen_intent_lexicon.py --check drift gates (neither was wired; LEVEL0.md claimed otherwise). 401 tests green + 129 observed re-run; fixed 2 stale DDL-count assertions (f1fb10b7 drift).
• Fixing 2 pre-existing test-isolation bugs flagged by L-D2/D4 builder at 2026-07-21 09:00 Details:
  • test_cov_knowledge_search.py::test_search_by_type_uses_correct_label seeded shared literal name 'do_test' (collides with leftovers from crashed runs); test_context_injector_task_types.py::test_summary_includes_specs_and_requirements_when_present used feature='auth' (production gateway.auth Modules leak into the pack, sections>2). Both fixed with test_id-embedded identifiers; observed verification run in flight.
• Semantic-graph QA benchmark executed (owed W9 item): 72% avg keyword coverage, 16/100 low-quality at 2026-07-21 09:02 Details:
  • Run after Memgraph chain drained, from repo root (chain's third step had the cwd bug). Results in plans/semantic_graph_qa_results_latest.md; rag-stack-evaluation.md §6 updated with re-ingest verification (694 Modules/1418 SemanticChunks/34 ArchitectureChunks) + hub-dominance analysis. Committed+pushed.
• BDD runtime-tracing Phase 0+1 (plans/bdd-runtime-tracing-plan.md) at 2026-07-21 09:16 Details:
  • Phase 0: harvest_test_citations extended to read @traces decorators on test defs (reuses core.tracing.scanner.collect_traces); +95 decorator ids, 233 unique harvested total (>=228 gate met)
  • Deleted stale docs/rtm.md + docs/rtm.json (self-contradicting legacy compliance-pipeline output, R-D1)
  • Closed the actual leak: _save_rtm_to_disk/persist_rtm now refuse empty project_dir instead of silently writing to CWD-relative docs/
  • Phase 1: new scripts/attribute_traces_runtime.py -- ctrace-core structural-fingerprint gate + 4-tier scored join (CONFIRMED/RUNTIME-CANDIDATE/STATIC-UNCONFIRMED/STATIC-UNTESTABLE)
  • Real-execution pilot (17 tests, 98% cov) + real context_pack slice reproduced REQ-106-063 nomination on relevance.py:rescore_by_tier exactly
• Landed BDD Phases 0-1 (376896bd) + CodebaseTools W4#1 (0c4b3a28) + investigation reports corpus (76a5ccda) at 2026-07-21 09:30 Details:
  • BDD: decorator harvest (CITED 139->213), attribute_traces_runtime.py, legacy RTM deleted with the real regeneration leak fixed (compliance save_rtm_to_disk empty project_dir). CodebaseTools: 4 codebase* tools in AGENT_TOOLS for U:Ar/U:Cd/U:SD/U:BA + production KB auto-index lifecycle.
• SPEC-108 environment replication installer: claude-env/install.sh hardened (preflight, PEP 668 deps, 17 PEP 758 fixes, session_cli init bootstrap fix), install-infra.sh (dual-backend incus/docker + terraform), infra/docker/infra-compose.yml; verified on clean Ubuntu 24.04 container + VM (fleet HEALTHY, data-path smoke green) at 2026-07-21 12:33
• Coverage-instrumented full suite: TOTAL 97.3% (67,648 stmts, 1,828 missed), 19:24 wall under --cov overhead; clean timed run launched separately for the speed number at 2026-07-21 12:53

Artifacts

• scripts/check_prolog_boundary.py (968 lines) - Prolog boundary gate: AST discovery + real-janus existence check- tests/scripts/test_check_prolog_boundary.py (700 lines) - 35 real-infra tests, 99% coverage- scripts/gen_intent_lexicon.py (120 lines) - specs/108-environment-installer/spec.md - docs/environment-replication.md - claude-env/install-infra.sh

Achievements

• CodebaseTools (Prolog codebase-intelligence, 791x-benchmarked) converted 0%->100% utilization: 4 tools (codebase_impact/module_deps/find_cycles/dep_path) wired to Ar/Cd/SD (all four) + BA (impact/module_deps); production KB lifecycle (_build_production_kb: mtime-based attach-vs-reindex, project-root-anchored ORCHESTRATA_CODEBASE_KB_DIR/ORCHESTRATA_AST_SNAPSHOT) replaces the permanent not_loaded stub. 304 tests passed / 0 failed across the touched+adjacent suite; tool_registry.py 97%, base.py 90%, codebase_query_tools.py 98% coverage. Fixed 1 unrelated pre-existing pyright error (test_extract_aider_prompt_present None-narrowing) hit while touching codedirector/test_volk.py.
• W1 governance wiring P1+P2 LANDED (commits 9c163691 + 027ed423, pushed): all 8 contract defects (F2-F6, F8) fixed with real-rules tests; 5 bonus boundary-gate findings fixed (violation/4 metrics always-0, dead safe_mode_active, errored sla_threshold, existence-error sentinel, dead resolve_ambiguity whitelisted with expiry); the boundary gate itself wired BLOCKING into run_tests/health_check/code-review and landed green (133 sites, 0 mismatches). P3/P5/P6 + G-D3/G-D4 triggers now armed.
• W9 grpc aio exit-hang FIXED and landed (efe8a6f8): root cause = fire-and-forget signal-handler stop() abandoning live grpc.aio.Server (never-called stop on exception paths) → del on closed loop → corrupted global refcount → shutdown_grpc_aio assert aborts before non-daemon thread joins. Fix: shared run_serve_lifecycle try/finally in cxp/grpc_server.py adopted by both _serve() entry points + module-scoped loop for test_server.py + tightly-gated interactive hard-exit (skipping shutdown_grpc_aio — calling it on the corrupted state segfaults). Proof: full tests/knowledge_graph 1871 passed, process exits cleanly in 231s. Residual refcount race confirmed upstream-identical in stock grpcio 1.81.1 — source fix queued against next FT-grpcio rebuild.
• W1 P3+P5 LANDED (commits P5 + b0e18dd6, pushed): ONE blessed governance loader now feeds both production seams (dispatcher policy-evaluator factory — where P2's ownership fix had been silently inert — and cli_main boot); GOVERNANCE_RULE_FILES expanded 7→9 (intent_policy.pl, postman_governance.pl; F5 closure); 31-test e2e enforcement-proof suite in tests/governance/e2e/ with retro-incident tests + AST circularity-guard; 4 hardcoded loaded==7 assertions generalized to len(GOVERNANCE_RULE_FILES). 207 passed observed across all affected surfaces; boundary gate rc=0. P6 (verdict provenance + boot health + proof-tree explanations) launched on the fired trigger.
• W1 P6 LANDED (44e2f8b7): verdict provenance (POLICY_/ERROR_ x ALLOW/DENY) emitted from every governance enforcement surface + boot health line at both production seams + DENY goal-chain explanations — the instrument the ratified G-D1 deny-flip is gated on. The routing timeout/query-error ERROR_ALLOW gap P6 surfaced was fixed in the same landing (governance_strict routing, both enshrining tests rewritten to assert both postures). Also fixed the 2 'n == 7' load-count assertions the b0e18dd6 sweep missed (17 errors on master). 160 passed observed; gate rc=0; W1 now complete through P6 — only P7 (promotions table, ORCH) remains.

Upcoming

• Proof-tree explanations for governance Prolog decisions (prolog/explain.pl)

Handoff

Decisions: docs/rtm.md + docs/rtm.json deleted (R-D1) -- the standalone generator script was already deleted 2026-07-09; the real leak was ComplianceVolk._save_rtm_to_disk writing to CWD-relative docs/ on empty project_dir, now refused, ctrace-core verification uses a structural fingerprint (cross-context line re-recording), not a stored metadata flag -- coverage.py persists no 'which core' field, contrary to the brief's assumption; verified empirically Blockers: Active Work: Phase 2 (run_tests.py --attribute wiring) and Phase 3 (EXECUTED grade + provenance + --runtime writer) remain open, both BLOCKED-adjacent on user decisions D1-D5 Key Files: scripts/attribute_traces_runtime.py, scripts/generate_rtm_evidence.py, src/orchestrata_ultimate/agents/volks/compliance/_pipeline.py, tests/scripts/test_attribute_traces_runtime.py, tests/scripts/test_generate_rtm_evidence.py, tests/agents/volks/compliance/test_pipeline.py Commands: uv run python scripts/attribute_traces_runtime.py --coverage-db <db> --src <dir> --tests <dir>, uv run python scripts/generate_rtm_evidence.py Alerts: Phase 4 and D1-D5 still need explicit user sign-off per the plan <<<<<<< Updated upstream

Record 2 — 2026-07-21 08:59 · Claude Opus 4.6 · archive (context.history.md)

Purpose

Build Phase 1 of the Prolog governance wiring plan: check_prolog_boundary.py gate + tests + wiring into health_check/code-review/run_tests

Objectives

• AST-discover Prolog query sites
• Consult shipped .pl into real janus and check existence
• Wire into 3 gates
• Real-infra tests, no mocks

Work log

1. Built the Prolog boundary gate and wired it into health_check.py, code-review.py (BOUNDARY), run_tests.py gates
   • Discovery handles direct seam calls, executor indirection, and multi-hop passthrough helpers (F2 shape)
   • Full-corpus existence check via current_predicate(_:F/A) against load_governance_rules() + every other shipped .pl
   • 38-entry WHITELIST for genuinely-dynamic sites with justifications
   • Live gate found 5 real defects beyond the original 8 (which the concurrent P2 builder fixed during this session)
2. W3 L-D2+L-D4 landed: generated intent lexicon + canonical re-exports (commit c980f8af, pushed)
   • intent_lexicon.gen.pl (58+26 facts) generated from IntentVocabulary.default() by scripts/gen_intent_lexicon.py; intent_grammar.pl includes it (16+13 silently-missing keywords now live — 'cleanup the parser module' classifies REFACTOR/CODE via DCG tier). schema.py/types_enums.py constants re-export canonical_schema (21+12 labels/rels + 12 enum members; Method/UnresolvedCall/UnresolvedClass/Document stay hand-authored per canon deferral). CI: wired gen_level0.py --check AND gen_intent_lexicon.py --check drift gates (neither was wired; LEVEL0.md claimed otherwise). 401 tests green + 129 observed re-run; fixed 2 stale DDL-count assertions (f1fb10b7 drift).
3. Fixing 2 pre-existing test-isolation bugs flagged by L-D2/D4 builder
   • test_cov_knowledge_search.py::test_search_by_type_uses_correct_label seeded shared literal name 'do_test' (collides with leftovers from crashed runs); test_context_injector_task_types.py::test_summary_includes_specs_and_requirements_when_present used feature='auth' (production gateway.auth Modules leak into the pack, sections>2). Both fixed with test_id-embedded identifiers; observed verification run in flight.
4. Semantic-graph QA benchmark executed (owed W9 item): 72% avg keyword coverage, 16/100 low-quality
   • Run after Memgraph chain drained, from repo root (chain's third step had the cwd bug). Results in plans/semantic_graph_qa_results_latest.md; rag-stack-evaluation.md §6 updated with re-ingest verification (694 Modules/1418 SemanticChunks/34 ArchitectureChunks) + hub-dominance analysis. Committed+pushed.
5. BDD runtime-tracing Phase 0+1 (plans/bdd-runtime-tracing-plan.md)
   • Phase 0: harvest_test_citations extended to read @traces decorators on test defs (reuses core.tracing.scanner.collect_traces); +95 decorator ids, 233 unique harvested total (>=228 gate met)
   • Deleted stale docs/rtm.md + docs/rtm.json (self-contradicting legacy compliance-pipeline output, R-D1)
   • Closed the actual leak: _save_rtm_to_disk/persist_rtm now refuse empty project_dir instead of silently writing to CWD-relative docs/
   • Phase 1: new scripts/attribute_traces_runtime.py -- ctrace-core structural-fingerprint gate + 4-tier scored join (CONFIRMED/RUNTIME-CANDIDATE/STATIC-UNCONFIRMED/STATIC-UNTESTABLE)
   • Real-execution pilot (17 tests, 98% cov) + real context_pack slice reproduced REQ-106-063 nomination on relevance.py:rescore_by_tier exactly
6. Landed BDD Phases 0-1 (376896bd) + CodebaseTools W4#1 (0c4b3a28) + investigation reports corpus (76a5ccda)
   • BDD: decorator harvest (CITED 139->213), attribute_traces_runtime.py, legacy RTM deleted with the real regeneration leak fixed (compliance save_rtm_to_disk empty project_dir). CodebaseTools: 4 codebase* tools in AGENT_TOOLS for U:Ar/U:Cd/U:SD/U:BA + production KB auto-index lifecycle.
7. SPEC-108 environment replication installer: claude-env/install.sh hardened (preflight, PEP 668 deps, 17 PEP 758 fixes, session_cli init bootstrap fix), install-infra.sh (dual-backend incus/docker + terraform), infra/docker/infra-compose.yml; verified on clean Ubuntu 24.04 container + VM (fleet HEALTHY, data-path smoke green)
8. Coverage-instrumented full suite: TOTAL 97.3% (67,648 stmts, 1,828 missed), 19:24 wall under --cov overhead; clean timed run launched separately for the speed number

Artifacts

• scripts/check_prolog_boundary.py (968 lines) - Prolog boundary gate: AST discovery + real-janus existence check
• tests/scripts/test_check_prolog_boundary.py (700 lines) - 35 real-infra tests, 99% coverage
• scripts/gen_intent_lexicon.py (120 lines)
• specs/108-environment-installer/spec.md
• docs/environment-replication.md
• claude-env/install-infra.sh

Achievements

• CodebaseTools (Prolog codebase-intelligence, 791x-benchmarked) converted 0%->100% utilization: 4 tools (codebase_impact/module_deps/find_cycles/dep_path) wired to Ar/Cd/SD (all four) + BA (impact/module_deps); production KB lifecycle (_build_production_kb: mtime-based attach-vs-reindex, project-root-anchored ORCHESTRATA_CODEBASE_KB_DIR/ORCHESTRATA_AST_SNAPSHOT) replaces the permanent not_loaded stub. 304 tests passed / 0 failed across the touched+adjacent suite; tool_registry.py 97%, base.py 90%, codebase_query_tools.py 98% coverage. Fixed 1 unrelated pre-existing pyright error (test_extract_aider_prompt_present None-narrowing) hit while touching codedirector/test_volk.py.
• W1 governance wiring P1+P2 LANDED (commits 9c163691 + 027ed423, pushed): all 8 contract defects (F2-F6, F8) fixed with real-rules tests; 5 bonus boundary-gate findings fixed (violation/4 metrics always-0, dead safe_mode_active, errored sla_threshold, existence-error sentinel, dead resolve_ambiguity whitelisted with expiry); the boundary gate itself wired BLOCKING into run_tests/health_check/code-review and landed green (133 sites, 0 mismatches). P3/P5/P6 + G-D3/G-D4 triggers now armed.
• W9 grpc aio exit-hang FIXED and landed (efe8a6f8): root cause = fire-and-forget signal-handler stop() abandoning live grpc.aio.Server (never-called stop on exception paths) → del on closed loop → corrupted global refcount → shutdown_grpc_aio assert aborts before non-daemon thread joins. Fix: shared run_serve_lifecycle try/finally in cxp/grpc_server.py adopted by both _serve() entry points + module-scoped loop for test_server.py + tightly-gated interactive hard-exit (skipping shutdown_grpc_aio — calling it on the corrupted state segfaults). Proof: full tests/knowledge_graph 1871 passed, process exits cleanly in 231s. Residual refcount race confirmed upstream-identical in stock grpcio 1.81.1 — source fix queued against next FT-grpcio rebuild.
• W1 P3+P5 LANDED (commits P5 + b0e18dd6, pushed): ONE blessed governance loader now feeds both production seams (dispatcher policy-evaluator factory — where P2's ownership fix had been silently inert — and cli_main boot); GOVERNANCE_RULE_FILES expanded 7→9 (intent_policy.pl, postman_governance.pl; F5 closure); 31-test e2e enforcement-proof suite in tests/governance/e2e/ with retro-incident tests + AST circularity-guard; 4 hardcoded loaded==7 assertions generalized to len(GOVERNANCE_RULE_FILES). 207 passed observed across all affected surfaces; boundary gate rc=0. P6 (verdict provenance + boot health + proof-tree explanations) launched on the fired trigger.
• W1 P6 LANDED (44e2f8b7): verdict provenance (POLICY_/ERROR_ x ALLOW/DENY) emitted from every governance enforcement surface + boot health line at both production seams + DENY goal-chain explanations — the instrument the ratified G-D1 deny-flip is gated on. The routing timeout/query-error ERROR_ALLOW gap P6 surfaced was fixed in the same landing (governance_strict routing, both enshrining tests rewritten to assert both postures). Also fixed the 2 'n == 7' load-count assertions the b0e18dd6 sweep missed (17 errors on master). 160 passed observed; gate rc=0; W1 now complete through P6 — only P7 (promotions table, ORCH) remains.

Upcoming

• Proof-tree explanations for governance Prolog decisions (prolog/explain.pl)

Handoff

• Key decisions: docs/rtm.md + docs/rtm.json deleted (R-D1) -- the standalone generator script was already deleted 2026-07-09; the real leak was ComplianceVolk._save_rtm_to_disk writing to CWD-relative docs/ on empty project_dir, now refused, ctrace-core verification uses a structural fingerprint (cross-context line re-recording), not a stored metadata flag -- coverage.py persists no 'which core' field, contrary to the brief's assumption; verified empirically
• Blockers: None
• In-progress: Phase 2 (run_tests.py --attribute wiring) and Phase 3 (EXECUTED grade + provenance + --runtime writer) remain open, both BLOCKED-adjacent on user decisions D1-D5
• Important files: scripts/attribute_traces_runtime.py, scripts/generate_rtm_evidence.py, src/orchestrata_ultimate/agents/volks/compliance/_pipeline.py, tests/scripts/test_attribute_traces_runtime.py, tests/scripts/test_generate_rtm_evidence.py, tests/agents/volks/compliance/test_pipeline.py
• Commands: uv run python scripts/attribute_traces_runtime.py --coverage-db <db> --src <dir> --tests <dir>, uv run python scripts/generate_rtm_evidence.py
• Warnings: Phase 4 and D1-D5 still need explicit user sign-off per the plan

Related

• Session log
• Session timeline
• Orchestrata Ultimate — project index
• Workflow